Goodwill Told Me ‘No’—Here Are 7 Items You Should Never Donate

We’ve all heard the saying, “One person’s trash is another person’s treasure.” While donating to charity is a great way to give back, not everything belongs in a donation box.

In fact, some items can create more problems than they solve—costing charities time, money, and resources to dispose of.

Professional organizer Clara Schoen, owner of The Home Organized in Birmingham, Alabama, emphasizes the importance of thoughtful giving:
“We should all strive to be conscious donors—real people are working at these places, and half of what they receive is just put in the trash.”

Before you load up your car with donations, check this list of seven items that most charities can’t accept—and better alternatives for them.

1. Used Toys and Games with Missing Pieces

While gently used toys and board games are welcome, incomplete sets often end up in the trash. Charities like Goodwill and the Salvation Army lack the resources to sort or fix missing pieces. Instead, consider repurposing old toys for craft projects or donating them to organizations that refurbish items for children in need.

2. Baby Gear

Items like car seats, strollers, and baby swings might seem like great donations, but safety regulations and expiration dates make them risky for resale. Many charities cannot legally accept these items due to liability concerns. Instead, check with local parenting groups, shelters, or hospitals—some may have programs for families in need.

3. Hazardous Materials

Paints, cleaning chemicals, batteries, and other hazardous materials should never be donated. These items require special disposal to prevent environmental damage and health risks. Look for hazardous waste recycling programs in your area to dispose of them properly. Electronics with Damaged Batteries

FYI, laptops, phones, and tablets with swollen or leaking batteries pose a fire risk.

4. Overly Worn Clothes and Shoes

While thrift stores happily accept clothing, items that are too stained, torn, or worn out won’t make it to the sales floor. Instead of donating unusable clothing, consider textile recycling programs that turn old fabric into industrial rags, insulation, or new materials.

5. Old Electronics

Outdated TVs, computers, and microwaves are often more trouble than they’re worth. Many charities lack the means to test, repair, or responsibly dispose of broken or obsolete electronics. Instead, check for electronics recycling programs—some manufacturers and retailers offer free take-back services.

6. Large Appliances

Washing machines, refrigerators, and dryers may seem like generous donations, but most charities can’t handle them due to size, weight, and disposal costs. If your appliance is still functional, try selling or giving it away through local marketplaces or donating to specialized organizations that refurbish appliances.

7. Mattresses and Box Springs

Due to hygiene concerns, most donation centers won’t accept mattresses. They can harbor bedbugs, mold, and allergens, making them a health risk. Instead, check for mattress recycling programs in your area—many cities have options for responsible disposal.

Give Thoughtfully, Donate Responsibly

By being mindful of what we donate, we help organizations focus their resources where they’re needed most—rather than sorting through unusable items. The next time you declutter, consider whether your donation is truly helpful or if there’s a better way to repurpose it.

Would you have guessed these items weren’t welcome at donation centers? Let us know in the comments!

Picture Designed By Freepik

Amazon’s Best Current Deals 👌👇